How the numbers work
Every figure is an estimate with a named source. The housing authority always makes the final call on rent.
The rent we underwrite
1. We start with the HUD rent that applies to the ZIP for fiscal year 2027. In the 65 metro areas where HUD requires Small Area Fair Market Rents, that is the ZIP-level figure. Everywhere else it is the area-wide Fair Market Rent, unless the housing authority has opted in to ZIP-level rents.
2. The housing authority turns that into a payment standard, usually between 90% and 110% of the HUD figure. Where we have loaded the authority's own published schedule we use it. Where we have not, we estimate and say so.
3. The payment standard is set by the smaller of the home's bedrooms and the tenant's voucher size. A four-bedroom home rented to a three-bedroom voucher is paid as a three-bedroom.
4. When the tenant pays utilities, the utility allowance comes off what the landlord collects.
5. The rent also has to pass the housing authority's rent reasonableness test, so where we have a market rent estimate for the home we cap the rent at it.
Cash flow
Rent, less vacancy, maintenance, management, a capital reserve, property taxes, insurance, any HOA fee and the loan payment. Defaults: 20% down on a 30-year loan at the weekly average 30-year rate plus one point for investor loans, 3% closing costs, 4% vacancy, 8% maintenance, 8% management, 5% capital reserve, and a make-ready repair budget based on the year the home was built. You can change every one of them on any deal.
Year-one cash flow also takes off the weeks with no rent while the unit is inspected and the housing assistance contract is signed (45 days by default).
The grade
A score out of 100: cash-on-cash return 30, monthly cash flow 25, debt coverage 15, rent-to-price 15, rent confidence 10, listing freshness 5. A is 75 or more, B 60, C 45. Any deal that loses money each month is a D, and a deal whose rent is only estimated cannot score above B.
Sources
- HUD Fair Market Rents and Small Area Fair Market Rents, fiscal year 2027, and HUD's list of designated Small Area FMR metro areas (August 2024).
- Housing authority payment standards and utility allowance schedules, from each authority's own published documents, with the effective date shown on the deal.
- Property listings, property records and market rent estimates from RentCast.
- 30-year mortgage rate: Freddie Mac Primary Mortgage Market Survey via FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
- ZIP code to city and county: GeoNames postal code data, CC BY 4.0.
- Maps: OpenFreeMap, © OpenMapTiles, data © OpenStreetMap contributors.
Property taxes are a state-average estimate until a county figure is available, and insurance is estimated from the price. Replace both with real quotes before you make an offer.